Running Time: 135 minutes
And oh, what a wonderful 135 minutes those are – if you are a fan of the Louisa May Alcott books “Little Women” and “Good Wives” (which is probably better known as the second part of Little Women).
I think Greta Gerwig is a genius, mostly for how well she understood the story and the characters enough, that I – who has disliked Amy March forever – really loved her too in this film.
Most adaptations focus on Jo March, obviously – but giving Amy infinitely more dimensions (God bless you, Florence Pugh) breathed new life into it. I know the book pretty much by heart and I am mostly set in my ways and opinions on it; Greta Gerwig managed to change my mind and revisit things in a new perspective.
I think a major problem with the Laurie-Amy arc is that it felt too sudden. Like, yeah, Laurie spent time with Amy when she was at Aunt March’s house during Beth’s bout with scarlet fever in Book I, but Laurie was basically a babysitter. Then everything in Europe happened quickly and you just don’t feel like anything except that Laurie settled for Amy to become a legit member of the March family, just because he couldn’t have Jo.
In this film however, they really set it up at every turn so that Amy gets our empathy. Her adoration for Laurie is evident from the start, so much so that when he finally turns to her, it physically hurt me when Florence Pugh tells Timothee Chalamet (aka the most gorgeous Laurie ever, don’t @ me) that she will “not be second to Jo…. Not when I’ve (Amy) loved you my entire life.”
Did you hear that? The sound of my heart breaking? The tissues I used up?
ALSO this adaptation gave us the hottest Professor Bhaer. Good Lord, with his sleeves rolled up and dancing and laughing with Jo? I was dying. The actor’s name is Louis Garrel, I am told by Wikipedia, and he is French so he mostly stars in French films. But get this, he is super duper cute – so it makes you understand how Josephine “Jo” “I’m never going to marry” March would be charmed by him at least. He gave her a set of Shakespeare plays and critiqued her writing. S W O O N.
I need to get back on track now. Saoirse Ronan’s Jo is a lovely, relatable mess. Winona Ryder’s 1994 Jo was also very good, but Saoirse gave her more roughness and vulnerability, which is really very Jo. Her chemistry with Timothee Chalamet was on-point as well, all affectionate and sibling-like. (I should quit my day job and become a full-time Timothee Chalamet stan account – despite having only watched his performance here.)
As is tradition in the Little Women canon, we don’t get much of Beth. I was pleased to see more of the details of her story come to life, though. The dolls she always cared for, the slippers she makes for Mr. Lawrence, and all of that – really, they got most of the details on-point. They show us Amy pinching her nose, rather than using the clothespin too, which is fine I guess.
Emma Watson is always a victim of detail though. They turn her dress pink (again! like Hermione’s Yule Ball dress!) rather than blue. I also wish there were more Daisy/Demi antics because that chapter was a laugh. Truly, I appreciated that the story chose to focus on the aspect of Meg wanting the finer things, a struggle she had to contend with until adulthood, but I wish they also included the part where the society matrons gossiped about her and Laurie to show the expectations people had for Meg, and how she followed her parents’ footsteps and disappointed these in favor of true love.
I also loved the two alternate endings: the one the publisher wanted for Jo which was romance and marriage and babies, but also the one Jo won for herself: independence and a book baby. I’m thrilled Greta Gerwig and the cast really were able to condense such a vast source material and refine everything, even the characters, so that we get this shining example of a well-done and refreshed adapatation. Cheers!
Unpopular opinion: they did not deserve to win the Best Costume Oscar, however. I said what I said. The Oscars are suckers for period costumes, but they don’t see the faulty construction of it all. Ugh.
Song rec of the week: A Party Song (Walk of Shame) by All Time Low